InSight

Market InSights:

Tesla added to S&P500

Today is the last day that Tesla will not be part of the S&P. S&P Dow Jones Indices has announced Tesla’s addition Friday after the market close. Tesla will officially trade as a member of the S&P 500 by the time the market opens on Dec. 21. Today’s buy of Tesla at the market close will likely be the biggest buy order ever.

This means Tesla joins the S&P at today’s closing price, the volatility is already high because it is also the quadruple witching quarterly options expiration.

Some highlights you should know about TSLA’s inclusion:

  1. The addition of Tesla will cause the largest rebalancing ever of the S&P 500 ever – Tesla is the 9th largest company by market capitalization. Because most of the investments that track the SP500 are weighted by market cap, they will be adding more TSLA than anything else. It will represent about 1.5% of the index going forward. 
  2. The liquidity for Tesla will increase, as these passive funds enter the space, the access to TSLA will increase. Both to borrow and trade the access to TSLA should see some much needed liquidity.
  3. This will stabilize the historically volatile stock. The swings both directions on Tesla have been pretty epic over its lifespan. Expect that to temper somewhat. This won’t change Elon’s flagrant tweeting, or the inherently volatile relationship this company has with investors, but over time, such a large holding from passive tools like SPY will bring the range down on its intraday swings. Inversely, TSLA will start to bring its price instability to bear on the SP500 adding to its aggregate volatility.
  4. If you own exposure to U.S. Large Cap ETF’s and mutual funds, you will own more TSLA going forward. There is nothing you need to do to get the exposure. If you already own the TSLA stock outright, it is adding to the exposure. It’s likely time to rebalance.
  5. The SP500 will get a shot in the arm on the P/E ratio – expect this to jump suddenly, there is nothing wrong with the readout, TSLA’s PE (today) is close to 1300. Meaning you have to pay $1,300 for every dollar TSLA earns. Before today the PE on the broader SP500 was 37 (already high) and expect the bellwether that is Tesla to cause that further distortion. This inclusion may permanently impair any comparisons you or your broker has made to the PE of the SP500.
  6. Inclusion of TSLA, will cause some forced selling of other names of make room. Fund will have to make room for Tesla, and will push out 1.5% from the other names to make room.

The closest similarity we can draw is when Yahoo was added. It too was not a member of an S&P small or midcap index prior to its inclusion and had a similar rush to buy when it was included in 1999. As a reminder, this was considered the beginning of the “tech bubble” by many. Yahoo stock rose 50% between the announcement and its entry into the index at the time. 

Some funds have been adding to the TSLA position, in anticipation of this inclusion, but many passive funds are not allowed to until today, as close to the close as possible.

More related articles:

Articles
Kevin Taylor

Obituary: the 60/40 Portfolio

The 60/40 portfolio was born in 1952 in Chicago, IL to Harry Markowitz. It received widespread adoption in the investment community and Nobel Prize accolades. The practice of balancing the correlation between stocks and bonds has died; on March 23rd, 2020. It is survived by a whirlwind of speculation, hedging, and general uncertainty. In lieu of flowers, please send condolences to the risk adverse. If you are familiar with the 60% stock/40% bond portfolio, you know it is largely a relic of the past. For most investors, alternatives and derivatives are likely to become a bigger portion of investors’ portfolios over the next decade. But for decades, investors would reliably count on exposure to 60% stock market equities and 40% bonds to create predictability and smooth out the stock market’s volatility. All with the hope they could still meet retirement goals. This is no longer the case. Cause of Death The cause death is not entirely clear, though there are several compounding maladies: Age: While in its youth the 60/40 performed admirably in its ability to predictably drive income through the ebb and flow of the market. Constantly providing investors with assets in a favorable asset class to be selling, and in turn working additional capital into an out of favor class. The whole process worked swimmingly shifting money back and forth and ever higher. But as this process aged it no longer kept up with changes to the economy. A relentless expansion of the national balance sheet and synchronized expansion money in the supply has eroded the health and reliability of the “40” side of the portfolio and has caused investors to seek higher and higher levels of risks from bonds to accommodate the falling returns. With little to no reprieve from the declining health of bonds, and a limited upside in returns, the predictability of the 60/40 has been questionable as of late. Nothing is more emblematic of this then the current bond markets – in the high yield space debt is priced with almost no accounting for default risks – meaning more money is chasing falling yields and leaving discerning investors to question the urgency. Simultaneously, the negative and near zero rates on treasuries are punishing the most conservative investors. This means the entire bond structure is distorted by the seemingly endless printing of money. Purpose: The 60/40 portfolio was supposed to insulate investors when markets turned sour. Providing a reduction in overall volatility and replacing it with a predictable and stable trajectory. As investors are demanding more and more internal rate of return to meet their investment objective they are either assuming more and more risk without compensation.  Or they’re seeking alternatives that require private equity, hedging, real estate, and complexity to fabricate a stable return and lowered risk. Regarding the risk return balance, investors have been seeking more and more risk for their returns by either pushing dollars into the higher risk bond (as noted above) or out of bonds entirely. Many are finding that to secure their retirement expectations they are going to simply abandon the 60/40 for a higher admixture or equities. And with little or no negative impact for taking on that risk they are seemingly fine running their portfolio hot. In comes alternatives, which has been described as one of the next big trends to cultivate the desired returns for investors. Even Vanguard, a company rooted in the success of the everyday investor, began exploring alternatives, launching a private-equity fund in 2019. This will pose new challenges for mainstream investors who are categorically poor at pricing this unconventional asset class. This could mean that returns will be impacted by fund flows. With the addition of retail investors to the Vanguard platform a systemic pushing up of prices will lower returns for both retail and institutional investors. It will also cause another market where too much money is chasing too few assets. COVID-19: Correlation between asset classes has long been the lynchpin in making the 60/40 (and other Modern Portfolio Theory) concepts work. But as the correlation between bond prices and stock prices are moving in closer and closer lockstep, the advantages of correction are diminishing. No point in time was that more apparent then the sell off in March of every asset class. The volatility seen in stock, bonds and even precious metals during that time showed there is no longer a predictable flight to safety mentality that would give investors an out. Correlation Psychology: Part of this correlation between historically oppositional asset classes comes down to the psychology of the investors. Investors are now, possibly more than they were historically, hypnotized by the returns of the capital markets. So when confronted with a low risk low return asset class like the bond market as a whole they will simply take their money into equities, causing them to invest their bond money with the same reactionary mindset that they invest their equity money. This is causing the both stock and bond markets to become sensitive to emotion and the news cycle like never before. Distortion of risk and “bailouts”: As we have seen and continue to see governments around the world are ready and willing to bail out capital markets. Nowhere is this more apparent than in the United States. There the practice of supporting financial markets with added liquidity is having a two fold effect that erodes correlation. It is rewarding the riskiest investments like equities; and by printing money it’s adding more supply to bonds while driving yields lower. Essentially, this practice is borrowing risk compensation from bonds to create a floor for equities. Exchange Traded Funds: While there is fantastic value in the vehicle it is limited to equities. See while a fund that contributes more assets to a company with a growing market cap created a virtuous cycle in equities, in bond it creates a bubble. By weighting and ETFs net exposure based on market cap it means the companies that borrow more, get more money…imagine

Read More »
Articles
Kevin Taylor

How to Survive a Bear Attack? (Pt. 2)

Don’t Discard your Strategy During a Recession We own stocks for a very deliberate reason. These equities are inflation resistant, generate cash, and the good companies grow at a rate faster than the economy they are a part of. They change prices wildly in a recession as people try to determine the long-term value of those features, but at the end of a recession, it is the only asset class that will be worth more after the economic slowdown. Stock prices might be down, but that doesn’t mean you need to change the way you invest. Remember you own these assets for a reason. This thought process applies to both long-term and short-term investors, and retirees. Long-Term Investors Long Term investors have the most to gain from a recession. It is very likely younger investors have been buying stocks at historically high prices. Any investor that began building their portfolio after 2001 has only had three windows where the broad market was trading below its historical average. That’s right, with the exception of three small windows in the last 20 years investors have been “overpaying” for their exposure to the market. Long-term investors might see the next window opening before their eyes right now.  If you’re regularly adding funds to a long-term account, such as a 401(k) or IRA, don’t stop during a recession. That’s huge! If you place most of your money in stocks, don’t “chase performance” and sell out of them. They may be falling in price while bonds are rising in price. Don’t chase bonds, don’t chase life insurance schemes, and don’t try to buy and sell rapidly. Don’t change what you are buying for the long term, in favor of what you see in the short term. Take advantage of the discount in prices – and keep saving.  Short-Term Investors and Retirees Although you may be uncomfortable during a bear market, don’t be tempted to sell your stocks or stock mutual funds at a loss across the board. Make two things a priority, lower your risk, and focus on cash flow. This is a time to focus on quality investments, and pair down the speculative portions of the portfolio – this isn’t the market for moonshots. Begin by accepting that speculative bets might be lost forever and start looking for investments that will survive economic contraction.  If you need income right away, it would be best to have money set aside in cash and bonds before the downturn. That way, you can withdraw from your cash while you wait for stock prices to recover. Then look for investments that can safely replace the cash you need on an annual basis – bonds, real estate, and dividend stalwarts are the keys here. If you can create a cash balance, then you can keep your more speculative investments grinding through the economic slowdown. Ideally, if you are retired, you and your CFP® know what your annual need for cash is, and what investments and institutions are working to replace that cash as fast as it is used. Investing Before and During a Recession It’s easy to go wrong during a recession if you forget or don’t understand how certain investments perform during a downturn. Or how they are related to each other. The stock market is a forward-looking vehicle. Stocks represent your right to a company’s future cash flows. So when warning signs of a recession “hit” these are the most skittish assets and will react the most violently. This doesn’t necessarily mean these companies won’t survive the recession or even become better as a result. What it means is that the amount that other people are willing to pay for a company’s future earnings is lower. When the recession becomes a thing of the past, people will begin to overpay for earnings again, and this is where you want to be in a position to sell shares to those people.  Stock prices often fall months before a recession begins, which also means that they often bounce back up before the recession is declared over. You can miss an entire downturn if you only follow the news. That is why it is vital to know the signs of a recession and recovery, and how assets perform during those periods.  These are our general expectations of asset behavior during a recession: Stocks: Prices for stocks tend to fall before the downturn begins, often selling off even at the scent of a recession. Stocks are the most volatile and skittish, during a recession. But they also have the most to gain. Good companies buy back their own stock during a recession, smart investors buy more shares at lower prices, and recessions make good companies leaner, and more financially fit for the next business cycle.  Real Estate: After stocks, Real Estate is the second most appetizing asset in a recession. And for some, it might be the most appropriate risk. Real Estate investors get the luxury of not having the mark-to-market value of their portfolio put in front of their face. During a recession, they make known their real estate is “down” but they are rarely bombarded with the daily and hourly reminders of the real estate market. This does two things, it reinforces patience for the investor and shifts their focus to the income the property produces. Both of these are things we noted above that stock investors need to learn in a recession.  Bonds: Prices for bonds tend to rise during a recession which means their yield declines. Good bonds (that is to say Bond from good companies) will often be over pursued their security – leading to an opportunity to sell overpriced bonds to scared or unprepared investors. Historically, The Federal Reserve (the Fed) stimulates the economy by lowering interest rates and purchasing Treasury bonds. But for the coming recession, this may not be the expectation as the Fed is in the first innings of raising its rates. This might be the macroeconomic element that causes this

Read More »
credit card
Articles
Peter Locke

Should you pay off your credit card or save?

The short answer is usually to always pay off high interest erosive debt like a credit card first (The First 8 “Good” Money Habits). You cannot consistently return more than credit card interests rates, therefore, you should pay it off before you start saving. Credit card debt hurts your credit score and your ability to save. Although it is sometimes necessary to get through a difficult time, we recommend avoiding it at all costs. Interest rates on credit cards usually never get below double digits and average around 18-25%. Our rule of thumb is that if you cannot consistently, key word being consistently, earn more than the interest you’re being charged for the debt you’re taking on then you should pay that debt off as soon as you can before doing anything else. For small business owners, sometimes you need to take on debt in order to grow your business and that’s okay if you don’t do it through credit cards. Taking on debt to grow a business or to further your education is what we call accretive debt. Typically, you can get a bank loan with an interest rate between 3-10% for a business (lower if you have consistent cash flows and good credit and higher if you have little to no income and an average to lower credit score). However, if you decide not to get your affairs in order by getting a bank loan (you’ll need a business plan and income records) and you decide to take the easy way out then you’ll take on debt that will be extremely costly to get out of.  For example, let’s say you take on $10,000 of credit card debt at a 20% interest rate. If you decide to make small payments like let’s say $250 a month then it will take you 67 months to pay off and you’ll end up paying $6,616 in interest. Meanwhile, the business owner that had a business plan and records in order took out a $10,000 loan and paid it back in 45 months while only paying $1,185 in interest.

Read More »

Pin It on Pinterest