InSight

Tax Mitigation Playbook: Allowable closing expenses in 1031 Exchanges

Financial Planning Dentist

Selling and buying a home is full of fees, expenses, and individual line items that can confuse the process and generate much of the closing paperwork. When selling or purchasing an investment property in a 1031 exchange process, certain selling expenses paid out of the sales or 1031 exchange proceeds will result in a taxable event for the exchanger.

boulder financial planning experts with 1031 tax mitigation experience

The IRS is very clear about many of these costs of selling a property, for example, routine selling expenses such as broker commissions or title closing fees will not create a tax liability.  Inversely most operating expenses paid at closing from 1031 proceeds will create a tax liability for the exchanger.

The IRS, over time and in several notes, instructions and guidelines has made the following clear:

Allowable closing expenses for IRS 1031 exchange purposes are:

  • Real estate broker’s commissions, finder or referral fees
  • Owner’s title insurance premiums
  • Closing agent fees (title, escrow, or attorney closing fees)
  • Attorney or tax advisor fees related to the sale or the purchase of the property
  • Recording and filing fees, documentary or transfer tax fees

Closing expenses that result in a taxable event are:

  • Pro-rated rents
  • Security deposits
  • Utility payments
  • Property taxes and insurance
  • Associations dues
  • Repairs and maintenance costs
  • Insurance premiums
  • Loan acquisition fees: points, appraisals, mortgage insurance, lenders title insurance, inspections, and other loan processing fees and costs

To reduce the taxable consequences of these operating, financing, and other closing fees, try to:

  • Pay security deposits, pro-rated rents, and any repair or maintenance costs outside of closing, or deposit these amounts in escrow with the closing agent.
  • Treat accrued interest, prorated property tax payments, or security deposits as non-recourse debt that the exchanger is relieved of on the sale of their old property, which could be offset against the debt assumed on the replacement property. Note: this would only work if mortgage debt is obtained on the replacement property purchase that exceeds the mortgage debt paid off on the sale of the relinquished property.
  • Match any prepaid taxes or association dues credited to the investor against the unallowable closing expenses listed on the settlement statement.

Check with your tax advisor prior to the closing to review the closing settlement statements to determine if there is an opportunity to avoid a taxable transaction in your 1031 exchange. It’s possible that an exchanger has a long-term loss carry forward or non-recognized passive operating losses that could offset the taxable amount.

Please note that all material provided in this newsletter is for informational purposes only and the author is not providing legal, tax accounting, or other professional services. The accuracy of the information provided as it pertains to your situation is not guaranteed. Please seek professional consultation if legal, tax accounting, or other expert assistance is required.

More related articles:

Investment Bias: Hindsight

Hindsight bias is reading beneficial past events obviously predictable, and bad events as not predictable and without cause (called black swans). In the decade between 1999 and 2009, we have many explanations for poor investment performance. Brokers and talking heads alike have found a litany of blame for the unpredictability and volatility of markets in those times.  Terrorism, irrational exuberance, greed, and lack of oversight are often the source of blame, and it’s easier to call these “black swans” or isolated external impacts on markets. These events are frequently conveyed as unpredictable. Likewise, economic expansion, low borrowing rates, government spending are all seen in hindsight as obviously predictive. The truth is these are both predictive, and neither is predictive. The hindsight bias starts as an attempt to make sense of these events and form a narrative to justify them. The bias is not a history lesson – adding content is not the issue. The bias comes from the now formed belief that the actions were obviously rational because in the end they were fruitful. This is backwards logic, it’s as to say “I didn’t wreck the car because I predicted I wouldn’t wreck the car” after the car was not wrecked.  While these “prediction” events make for great marketing material, they make for poor logic. It assumes that an investor that takes ten outsized bets, sees three pay off well, three perform at market, three underperform and one bankrupt predicted the three that did well. Then in hindsight fills in the actions that prove the three great picks were obvious and predictable, and the bankruptcy is from something impossible to understand. This type of reconciliation after the fact leads an investor to become overconfident in their predictive capabilities, and understate their ability to put together the history in a positive way.   The “best idea” spin: Once an investor or investment company has those documented success stories they use them to attract new investors for their next ten picks. Believing that the success they had in investments 1, 2 and 3 were representative of their skill and the bankruptcy was unpredictable. This idea to spin the good isn’t new to the sales and marketing people and exploits the bias that events are predictable and through skill and time can be divined. This “feeling” of success is the bias, and that the belief that the next set of ten pick will have something to do with the last ten.

Read More »

Why should someone at my age start saving and what will it look like one day?

You should save if you don’t want to be reliant on an employer or the government to support you. For those like myself that love what they do for a living, I still don’t want to have to work. At InSight, we call this employment dependency. How long are you dependent on an employer to live and at what point can you stop working and live off your income from your investments? For those that don’t like what they do or aren’t thrilled about it, you probably don’t want to have to work more than you have to.  Well “have to” depends on what type of lifestyle you want to live. If you don’t want money to be a concern later in life then you should start saving now. If you’re able to live a frugal lifestyle you should still be saving just not as long as others that want more income. Keep in mind that a dollar today is not worth the same as a dollar in 30 years so you need to know how inflation affects your plan.  My advice to those that want to be financially independent is to follow these steps: Step 1: Save at minimum 15% of your pretax income with a goal of 20% – 30% What about my living expenses? Outside of a few key expenses also called non-discretionary expenses (rent/mortgage, utilities, groceries) your formula should be “Income – SAVINGS = Expenses” Step 2: Automate your savings You love automating things like your Netflix subscription so why not automate your savings? Just like your 401(k), save anything you can into an investment account Log into your payroll system with your employer and go to the section where you put in your bank account. Add an account and make it an investment account. A simple brokerage account (i.e. Wealthfront, Vanguard, Betterment, etc) will do. For every paycheck take a fixed dollar amount or % and have it automatically deposited into your investment account. No matter how small the amount, create the savings habit now. Notice I didn’t save checking/savings accounts. Outside of your emergency fund (3-6 months of fixed expenses) every dollar needs to be working for you and making you money.  Step 3: Don’t touch it and barely look at it. Don’t link your bank account to it. Don’t download an app on your phone to look at it. Don’t think about it. The firms I listed (there are a lot of them) and InSight automate your investments and put them to work right away. Question: How much does saving $50 bi-weekly turn into after 10 years at 8% return? $79,676  What about $250 bi-weekly for 10 years at 8%? $398,384

Read More »
Articles
Kevin Taylor

529 College Planning: 102

Types of 529 plans This is one of the largest hang-ups for savers. A history of misinformation and contamination between different types of 529s has generated several misnomers. Simply put: 529 plans are usually categorized as “prepaid tuition” or “college savings plans.” Our favorite of the two is the college savings plan, and we find that several of the misconceptions that savers have come from the “prepaid” tuition plans.    For clarity, College Savings Plans work much like a Roth 401(k) or Roth IRA. They are investments made with post-tax dollars (that often carry tax benefits) and the accounts grow and earn income in a tax-free way. These accounts allow you to invest your after-tax contributions in mutual funds or similar investments. Most of the 529 college savings plans we work with offer several investment options from which to choose. The performance of the account will be tied to the investment options you chose, and you should consult a CFP® and your InSight-Full® to manage this risk, and coordinate it with your timing of needs. The other alternative, a Prepaid Tuition Plan,  lets you pre-pay all or part of the costs of an in-state public college education. They may also be converted for use at private and out-of-state colleges. The Private College 529 Plan is a separate prepaid plan for private colleges, sponsored by more than 250 private colleges. These programs are limited in scope, while they can support savers concerned with the rising costs of tuition, they are generally less flexible and have fewer payment and conversion options. They may also carry unique liquidity issues should you plan to change. It is an educational institution that can offer a prepaid tuition plan but not a college savings plan. What can’t I use my 529 plan for? The funds and the investments in a 529 plan are yours. You should be able to maneuver and control the funds in the account as you see fit and within your fiduciary scope. Also, you can always withdraw them for any purpose but should be mindful of the consequences. Chief among these is the earnings portion of a non-qualified distribution will be subject to ordinary income taxes and a 10% tax penalty, though there are exceptions and methods for managing this tax loss. At the college or post-secondary level, we discussed in “529: 101” the obviously covered costs of education and what the 529s have been expanded to include. Though you should be made aware that there are some costs that you may believe are necessary, but the IRS disagrees. For example, student health insurance and transportation costs are not qualified expenses, unless the college has lines out these associated costs in fees or services from the college. So, parking fees at Denver University campuses might be covered, but a space in a parking lot near campus might not be. Are 529 plan contributions tax-deductible? Unfortunately, the 529 is funded with post-tax dollars, and there is no federal tax relief yet. However, here in Colorado and in over 30 other states, they offer state income tax deductions for contributions to 529 plans. But it’s likely that like Colorado, you would be restricted to investing in your home state’s 529 plan in order to claim the state income tax benefit. (Consult a tax professional for more information) The tax advantage regarding federal taxes comes when the funds in a 529 plan grow. The growth in these plans is federally tax-free and will not be taxed when the money is withdrawn for qualified education expenses. Can I use a 529 plan to pay for rent? Yes, with some restrictions. Room and board is now a qualified expense for at least “half-time” or greater students. Consult with the institution for what constitutes a half-time student.  So for on-campus residents, qualified room-and-board expenses should not exceed the amount charged by the college for room and board. So in this case savers pay the room and board directly to the student housing authority to avoid mismanagement.  For students living off-campus, qualified room and board expenses are limited to the cost of attendance figures that vary from school to school. Contact the financial aid office for their reports on this figure. In these cases, try to find a 529 fund that supports payment directly to landlords. What happens if my child doesn’t use the 529 plan? There are always options for these funds. Hopefully, you are in this situation for a positive reason like a full-ride scholarship or attendance at a service academy. There are a few reasons to seek a waiver however, your earnings will still be subject to federal and sometimes state income tax. If this is the case the 10% penalty is waived if: The beneficiary receives a tax-free scholarship The beneficiary attends a U.S. Military Academy The beneficiary dies or becomes disabled If you want to avoid paying taxes completely you can resort to the following: Change the beneficiary to another qualifying family member (a parent, child, sibling etc.) Hold the funds in the account in case the beneficiary wants to attend grad school later Make yourself the beneficiary and further your own education Use a 529 ABLE account, a savings account specifically for people living with disabilities Since January 1, 2019, qualified distributions from a 529 plan can repay up to $10,000 in student loans per borrower over their lifetime for both the beneficiary and the beneficiary’s siblings As we said at the top of this article. you can withdraw any of the money in a 529 plan at any time for any reason. However, the earnings portion of a non-qualified withdrawal will be subject to taxes and a penalty. So in the absence of one of the exceptions listed above, we will usually coach our clients to find one of the other alternatives above and make these necessary changes to their InSight-Full® plan. If you are still contemplating a non-qualified distribution, be aware of the rules and possible tactics for reducing taxes owed.

Read More »

Pin It on Pinterest